JD14's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sonic Adventure 2 | Theme]

Nice man!

Okay, before the review, I have to tell you that the song's real name is Live And Learn, by Crush 40.
Okay, onto the review.
The instrument choice was great, I liked how you replaced the vocals with trumpets or horns or whatever they were lol. The main Guitar thing was nice :D
only thing you could work on is volume.
5/5 10/10 fav'd.

[Evil-Dog - The Last Stand]

Wow, man.

Okay first to start off, I noticed none of these reviews help you.. At all.
Theyre quite useless, and I plan to make mine stand out from the others.
Here goes:
I personally... LOVED this track. The main part of it was phenominal, you had one of the best ideas ever when you made this song.
The chorus was really well placed. The song stayed on beat throughout the whole song, and theres not much, or very little repetitiveness. The buildup and ending were great, I liked the fading effect, and how you took one instrument out one at a time. The Bass was a really good touch. The instrument choice period was... Perfect. The guitars sounded insanely real. I like the choice of how many you used, two was perfect for this. The violins sounded great in the background, and thats pretty much all I have to say. I couldn't find anything wrong with this. OH, one last thing, the reverse symbols = Perfect. It made the piece sound 10 times better.
I wonder sitting here in my seat how you came up with this song.
This is going in my favs list. 1st place. This deserves the top 5 of the week. And if it doesnt make #1 then NG doesnt know what theyre doing. I downloaded too. This is definately going into my MP3 Player. Seriously, you're like Goukisan only like with different guitars... And slower songs. 5/5 10/10 Fav'd Dl'd And guess what?
You're in my fav artists.

Evil-Dog responds:

I can't say this review helps me more than any other haha you only said good things :) so basicly I should keep making the same kind of stuff eh? hehehe
thanks for the long and kind review!
Cheers

[=Overdrive=]

BURP

Okay as soon as I heard this I was like.. Whoa, this is a nice song...
But then the UHH sounds came in which sounded like robotic burps... Lowered the score by one. Its got good rythm, its great techno in my opinion, but at some points it seemed just.. All thrown together. And it was pretty sure. So thats another point off.
In total, you get -2 points,
resulting in: 8 Stars, 4/5

[luigis mansion demo]

WTF ALREADY being downvoted?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!!!!

This song rocks dude. It totally doesnt sound like you just took a MIDI and re-edited it.
I love it. Perfect instrument choice, I like the part around 1:10, that sounded nice. The guitar was a nice effect, and the other FX just rocked.
"half the song is missing"
Well the give it a fucking five you fucking retarded douchebag!
Five for one half of a total of ten.
Im fiving this and faving it. Might even use it in a non-flash RPG Im working on. Not going to be commercial, so nothing too special.

[Flood Warning]

Sounds like rain.

I loved the sounds. The muffled sound in the beginning made it sound like a rainy day, and the echoing reminded me of raindrops falling off of leaves, the whole thing sounds like rain. I loved the higher-pitched noises that were also echoed that came in. Nice transitioning, and I just loved it overall. 10/10 5/5 fav'd DL'ed

EvilStereo responds:

Thanks!! Glad you could see what I was going for. :D

[The Waves]

Wow...

I loved it! Drums were really nice. And forget about that dude who said "bad could have done better" I bet hes just jealous x]
The umm stabbing-sort-of-noise that went with the beat around 1:10 was cool.
Kinda loud but still cool.
I really did like it tho. 10/10 5/5 fav'd.

[Adapt to the Horde (vocals)]

I loved the original too!

WOW! This made it so much better dude! I loved the original, and I had heard you were making a second one with vocals... Only complaint I have is that the vocals kinda get drowned out, otherwise PWNSOME man.

TwilightNecrosis responds:

Thanks!
Yeah, I fucking love this song, the riffs flow, the clean parts fit perfectly...I was really nervous to try to put vox on something that was already so good.
I noticed that they were a bit low in the mix after I'd already mixed it down, but it was too late to fix it, so I left it be.
Thanks again for the review, I appreciate it.
Metal forever!

[The Decisive Battle - FFVI]

Sounds like a MIDI...

Its good, especially since you got the notes all by yourself without using a MIDI as a base... Maybe you could try making the sounds different, making it sound more pleasant. Just a tip, people hate songs that sound like MIDIs... I would have given a 5 to a 5.5, but I raised it because this is made from scratch.

SuperFlonic responds:

Hmm, well I DID use only sounds from FL studio. Somehow they sound like MIDI, now you mention it. But this isn't a MIDI, I can assure you :) Can't upload MIDI's to NG, now can you.

But it's probably because of FL's Keys, they just sound like this. I guess I just have to find different drum kits and a different piano.

[Edd's Crappy Song]

Nice.

FUCK WHAT AvatarKami SAID!
She didnt provide any way to improve your song, so thats total crap,
the song isnt a bunch of things thrown together, its got a beat, so stfu.
The song had good rythm, even though it was a bunch of loops, I think its great!
I think you could improve by making that weird... Stabbing-sort-of-noise less loud, would make it easier to listen to.
10/10
5/5
Stfu Kami.
Fav'd.

[The..Ultimate.MasterHand]

Nice!

I loved it. It sounds so much like the original from Brawl and Melee!
I must say, for a videogame track, its one of the best I've heard.
"9/10- Video Game songs just arn't my thing. Sorry."
Well that should make you vote HIGHER. Its classified in Videogame, thats absolutely no reason to take off a point. I am not flaming, or anything relating to that, I am telling someone why they shouldn't take a point off for a song being in the right classification.
Anyway, I gave it a 5/5 10/10 :D